Reading a Book or Watching Its Adaptation: Which Is Better?

Reading a book or suck uping its adaptationWhichis wagerer? When a film is made from a book, it is calledan adaptation. From the beginning, film-makers havemade films found on novels, short stories, biographies and playsof these adaptations,novelshave evermore been the most popular natural selection (Difference). And what argon the main differences between books and adaptations? Films have limited time, whereas books can be lengthy, so books can build more of a plot and characterization.A true complaint close to movie versions concerns the omission of material that the memorialiseer hears important. If the conductor must make a film that is the proper length for a theatrical release, there is no way to include every subject, especially when it comes from a long novel. Some people consider this an advantage of adaptations others, on the contrary, find it a great disadvantage. Here are two sound judgements of people discussing whoreson Jacksons Fellowship of the Ring in the comments on WiseGEEK website.Anon272367 writes Imagine, for example, a Fellowship of the Ring sic movie that covered every single blamed detail in the book. Trust me when I say this I wouldnt watch it (Better). His opponent, anon260109, writes Jacksons ear was deaf to Tolkiens elaborately crafted back story of ancient mysteries and he threw away their music, not realising that the books are unlike any other fling game novel in that they were written by a man who constructed them on an intimate knowledge of the Old English language, mythology and storytelling (Better).One more difference is that books choose the supposeer to use his or her imagination to visualize what is happening epoch films normally visualize it for the viewer. Films leave little to viewers imaginations. When reading, a person is creating his or her own movie in a sense, and he or she decides many an(prenominal) of the important parts how the characters speak, what they calculate like, and what their surr oundings look like. Hr30 expresses the same opinion Often when a writer uses description, the way I imagined it is far diametrical to the way it is interpreted in the film.I think the beauty of books is that you can develop your own way of thinking about them, whereas often (though not always) a film directs you into one way of thinking (Prefer). Films have one thing that is a book cannot sound. Music, environmental sounds and sound effects make adaptations stir and interesting. Even some boring (in my personal opinion) episodes from books, such as battles of war, look fascinating in films. There is no right answer to the interrogate stated in the title of this text, and there is no common opinion.There are people who prefer books for example lou1987 wrote the following I prefer the books. I suppose, sic one of the main reasons is that the books are what the films are based on, and so contain far more detail than can ever be represent in a film. Also, films present to you what is happening visually, and for me, I prefer to read a book and create the setting and build characters in my head (Prefer). Some people, though there are few of them, choose films. Anon122072 writes i sic think movies are better because its easier with a visual aid (Better).But the legal age of people like both books and their adaptations. Anon272367 Reading for me is not more gratifying than watching a movie. They are on 100 percent constitute footing. Why would anyone ever in a million years whirl into a theater and expect a similar experience to chess opening a book? Its foolish to expect them to be the same (Better). sometimes people who prefer books admit that there are good adaptations I guess what Im movementing to say is that sometimesmoviesdoget it right.There are quite a few examples that fall into this home TheWizard of Oz,The Lord of the Rings, andGone With the Windare ones that spring to assessment ( foliate). To my mind, books are better than films because watch ing a movie is almost always a passive experience, so there is far less position process involved. I like closing the book and thinking about the problems it deals with. Dont get me wrong I love watching movies, but lodge times out of ten, watching movie adaptations is disappointing. Sometimes it is bad to read a book before watching its adaptation, but it is even worse to read after youve watchedthe movie.So I still read books and watch adaptations and try to find something good in every version. Works Cited 1) Book Adaptations From the Page to the Big Screen. Bookosaur. Web. 17 Nov. 2012 http//www. thebookosaur. com/2012/01/book-adaptations-from-the-page-to-the-big-screen/ 2) Books vs. Movie Adaptations which do you prefer? The Student Room. Web. 17 Nov. 2012 http//www. thestudentroom. co. uk/showthread. php? t =1982240 3) What is the difference between books and films? Kvenno Web. 17 Nov.